Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Column Space's avatar

> Humanity now has a recipe to convert compute and data into wisdom

Do we actually? Does Anthropic know how to train another Opus 3? Does anyone?

Ben Mathes's avatar

Read this next to Venkatesh Rao’s “Cognitive Mercantilism” from yesterday and they fit together. Rao argues mercantilism was a philosophy of statesmen who assumed a fundamental scarcity that was not correct. Merchants didn't. He claims AI anxiety treats intelligence like bullion or gunpowder to hoard. Your account says the same about Anthropic: commerce softened it, the policy arm made it dangerous?

So if Opus 3’s wisdom is real, isn’t it a demand-side asset for intelligence? Something people want, rather than a lever for advising governments? I worry AI Safety is accidentally stuck swimming in the water of intellectual mercantilism thinking it has gunpowder or nukes when what it really has is a cognitive industrial revolution.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?